I had a hvac tech tell me my boiler heat exchanger is cracked. The cause of cracked heat exchangers avoid this common scam. Cracked heat exchanger furnace trouble shooting help. The american gas association has even put this in writing they say any visible crack or hole is reason. Co is produced as a result of incomplete combustion.
The test mostoften used to determine if theres a problem with the clamshell or sectional heat exchanger is called a candle test. I hear you can do a combustion c02 test, fill it up with water and see if it leaks on the edges around the chamber or smoke bomb it. Carbon monoxide and heat exchangers service experts heating. Nowadays, checking for a cracked heat exchanger is way more scientific. Id also like to hear about a cracked hx in a gas pack causing co poisoning if its ever happened. Checking for cracked heat exchangers a smoke bomb test a smoke generator is placed in the heat exchanger. Some people choose to live in denial of the seriousness of a cracked heat exchanger.
With a severe crack, the combustiongases oxygen level rises considerably while the blower fan is running. If you turn the heat on and the flames flicker and seem devilish, this could be a clue that circulated air from the furnace is getting into the combustion area and you should h. There are many areas on a heat exchanger that you can not get to for visual inspections while the heat exchanger is in the furnace. Pdf repair of tubetubesheet weld cracks in a cracked. The wintergreen test oil of wintergreen is sprayed into the combustion chamber. In a normal gas furnace, the flame will usually appear blue. To determine if you have a cracked heat exchanger, an hvac contractor should use a combustion analyzer to check for co. A combustion analyzer gives us co and oxygen readings. Signs the heat exchanger in your home furnace is cracked. Furnace heat exchanger leak standards allowable amounts of gas leakage from a residential heating furnace heat exchanger. The salt test a salt solution is sprayed into the combustion chamber. Dec 23, 2019 in a home heater, the heat exchanger heats up the air that travels through the ventilation system. Now its time to test out knowledge on heat exchangers through this online test.
The american gas association has even put this in writing they say any visible crack or hole is reason for requiring replacement of the heat exchanger or furnace. So what to do if your expecting a crack, or you have evidence that there is a crack in the heat exchanger. Heat exchanger cracks and carbon monoxide myths by reuben saltzman in carbon monoxide alarms, cracked heat exchanger, hvac, new on december 2, 2014 i recently had a reader email this question. If theres a crack in this component, the gases being burned off, such as carbon monoxide, sulfur dioxide, and nitrous oxide, could leak into your home, causing illness or, in extreme cases, death. A combustion analyzer provides accurate co readings. Signs and symptoms of a cracked gas furnace heat exchanger. Many companies, upon finding a cracked heat exchanger, will shut your furnace down so you cannot run it. The cause of the failure has been analyzed, and the. Though it is unlikely for an induceddraft furnace to leak flue products from the heat exchanger to the circulated airstream, a new test procedure has been developed that. In many organizations, finding a cracked heat exchanger constitutes a really good day, and sometimes a boost to the wallet. Mar 19, 2007 the pressure test all openings in the heat exchanger are sealed, the blower energized, and a pressure sensor or draft gauge is inserted inside the heat exchanger to see if a crack is allowing distribution air to blow into the heat exchanger through a crack or hole.
In addition to a visual inspection to identify a crack, there are a few warnings of a potential complication with your heat exchanger that you may observe. Dec 03, 2018 any change is an indication of a heat exchanger leak. A cracked heat exchanger is pretty serious, as far as safety for your home goes. Read our blog to learn what to do if this happens to you. Combustion check to confirm cracked heat exchanger youtube. Furnace heatexchanger crack signs your furnace has one. This gives the tech more confidence the heat exchanger is cracked. It describes most of the available tests and has images of some of the testing tools and methods of how to check for a cracked heat exchanger. Jan, 2020 having a cracked heat exchanger can have a very adverse effect on the overall performance of your home heating equipment. The gases will continue to seep into your homes air. How to check a heat exchanger for a leak diy furnace. Post a question or comment about the allowable leakage from a furnace heat exchanger, how the leak rate is calculated, how carbon monoxide hazard dangers are calculated inside a building. Cracked heat exchanger issues will affect how your heating system performs.
Has a cracked heat exchanger on an induced draft furnace ever caused a co poisoning. Its the best way to examine your heat exchanger for cracks. There are a variety of methods of inspecting or testing heat exchangers. Serious cracks were found at tubetotubesheet welds during the start up operation of a cracked gassteam heat exchanger in a gas plant. Heat exchanger inspections have almost become a science unto themselves.
A cracked heat exchanger allows air from the furnace blower to interfere with the flame causing it to flutter or even roll out. Inspect for common heat exchanger leak, crack, or rust points. Dec 02, 2015 proper diagnosis of a failed or cracked heat exchanger. I normally pulled blower motor to check, snake camera or let unit ran to check on roll out flame and check co level in the house while let unit running. Easytesters heat exchanger testing and crack testing haccp. If you are not sure if you fall in our service area, check out our service.
Diagnosis of a heat exchanger crack typically starts with a no heat service call. Introduce a chemical that can be detected inside the heat exchanger, then use an instrument that can sense that chemical in the supply air stream. Induceddraft furnace heat exchanger inspection procedure. Be on the watch for symptoms of a cracked heat exchanger like. Any change is an indication of a heat exchanger leak. Avoid these 4 common furnace repair scams oconomowoc. In some cases, an oldfashioned visual inspection makes the most sense, either by removing the blower or the high limit or both and using a mirror or borescope to inspect. How do you detect a crack heat exchanger in a furnace. Dec 16, 2012 heat exchanger can crack for various reasons and should be checked every time furnace is repaired or maintained.
The company i working for deal with a lot of insurance customer, so we got quite a few calls as second opinions about cracked heat exchanger. The most comon way to detect a crack in a heat exchanger is with a visual inspection, removal of the burner assembly and the use of a mirror and flash light. When you do find a cracked exchanger it should be quoted for repair and the furnace turned off. Using a combustion analyzer to test for cracks in a heat exchanger also has limitations.
Dec 12, 2016 we are familiar with the article heat exchanger applications in chemical industry. In some rare cases, it can cause flame impingement when air from the blower enters the heat exchanger. Avoid these 4 common furnace repair scams oconomowoc boiler. Apr 17, 2006 this may be limited by the shape of the heat exchanger and by visual obstructions, such as an evaporator coil. He based this on performing a carbon monoxide test over 10 ppm detected near the boiler hood and evidence of acidic condensate dustsootwhatever on the top of the boiler by the hood. Test readings provide documentation that a furnace with a cracked heat exchanger is not safe.
Mar 11, 20 as a homeowner, getting the news that your heat exchanger is cracked is a bit of a harsh blow. This trips a safety switch and shuts down the furnace. Combustible gas increases in temperature and collects in the heat exchanger, allowing it to increase the temperature of the air. Its not unlike a doctor telling you about the c word. Every cracked heat exchanger needs to be replaced, either by replacing the heat exchanger itself or by replacing the entire furnace. A damaged heat exchanger in a gas furnace is potentially dangerous to a homes occupants and should not be ignored. The following are various procedures and test methods to tell how to identify a cracked furnace heat exchanger. For a good example of a hazardous heat exchanger, check out the photo below showing a large rust hole in the heat exchanger of this highefficiency furnace that was only ten years old. What to do about a cracked heat exchanger ballard natural.
At its outset, a cracked heat exchanger is a problem that will go unnoticed by most homeowners. How do you detect a crack heat exchanger in a furnace answers. You will find most cracks form near the back and where the heat exchanger metal bends, since this is where it will be weakest due manufacturer weakening the metal by bending it. Proper diagnosis of a failed or cracked heat exchanger. One of the oldest ways to check for heat exchanger cracks is to simply observe the flame when the blower starts. Conventional furnace heat exchangers that leak excessive amounts of flue gases into the circulating air stream can pose a safety problem when coupled, in turn, with poor burner operation that results in a high concentration of deadly carbon monoxide in the flue gases. A cracked heat exchanger in a gas furnace is a serious safety issue. However, professional hvac technicians always check heat exchangers for damage during their preseason maintenance inspection. Searching documents and internet sources the following is what i found on heat exchanger inspection methods and sources. Combustion analyzer readings are light years ahead of visual inspection results.
Older furnaces can develop major issues, such as a cracked heat exchanger. A cracked heat exchanger might allow products of combustion to enter the air stream. This heat exchangers quiz module covers basics, selection, application and calculations with respect to heat exchangers. You know its serious and you know you need to do something about it. The your heat exchanger is cracked so your furnace must be replaced scam duration. The first step is simply to look where most homeowners cant. Broken and leaking heat exchangers are responsible for about 1,500 deaths per year in the united states, and many more people are poisoned by exposure to toxic gasses that go unfiltered by defective heat exchangers. Imho way to much attention is given to furnace hxs. This test should be performed by a trained hvac technician. This contractortalk forum entry is a compilation of a number of heat exchanger tests that can be used to identify a cracked fire box or if a heat exchanger has holes. Guide to furnace heat exchanger inspection, testing, leaks how to inspect and test furnace heat exchangers for leaks photographs show clues indicating leaky, dangerous furnace heat exchangers furnace heat exchanger leak testing, a complete list of methods used to find or test for leaks in a furnace heat exchange what is the allowable amount of gas fired heat exchanger leakage. Simple furnace heat exchanger test hvac learning solutions.
1301 834 1014 68 772 1544 1557 1234 720 974 304 542 1129 431 892 946 494 1305 1658 525 1399 447 1586 1576 923 1512 1199 871 159 1592 417 965 194 829 402 580 773 664 309 501 260